- UID
- 2095
- Online time
- Hours
- Posts
- Reg time
- 31-7-2018
- Last login
- 1-1-1970
|
I am reading The 'Life and Times of Sir Pherozeshah Mehta' by VS Srinivasa Sastri, (the writer was a politician of the time). The subject was a an Indian barrister and political thinker who followed the Parsi religion and lived between 1845-1915.
The Genre is Non Fiction and is a 174 Pages Biography by an author who met and knew his subject personally. It was published in 1945, some thirty years after Mehta's death.
I would rate it 4/10 for the time being. This is because the book has no order, follows no specific patterns and digresses from one point to the next without explanations, footnotes or commentary to avoid confusion.
I chose the book because of four primary issues. The first two were because it was written by someone who knew the person being written about and second because it was recorded and made available not long after the subject passed away.
I was expecting some bias because the author admired his subject, and a professional academic work of repute due to the author's background as a parliamentarian but was disappointed on both fronts. I have found the book lacks flair, clarity and substance and equally so the bias is to the point of hero worship.
The next two were due to who admired and learned from him; namely Muhammad Ali Jinnah of Pakistan who worked in his law offices for a time and was also introduced to politics by Mehta. The other individual was Dadabahi Naoroji who although being twenty years older than Mehta worked with him and spoke highly of his friend as a fellow campaigner for the rights of Indians under British rule at the time.
As someone who has yet to finish it, I am hesitant to recommend it based on what I have read so far. |
|